jump to content
In the Network: Media Co-op Dominion   Locals: HalifaxTorontoVancouverMontreal

Life’s Too Short to Remain Powerless

  • warning: Creating default object from empty value in /var/alternc/html/f/ftm/drupal-6.9/sites/www.dominionpaper.ca/modules/img_assist/img_assist.module on line 1747.
  • strict warning: Declaration of views_handler_filter_date::exposed_validate() should be compatible with views_handler::exposed_validate(&$form, &$form_state) in /var/alternc/html/f/ftm/drupal-6.9/sites/all/modules/views/handlers/views_handler_filter_date.inc on line 0.
Issue: 76 Section: Environment Topics: climate justice

April 18, 2011

Life’s Too Short to Remain Powerless

by Members of the Vancouver Media Co-op

Photo: ZIG ZAG

VANCOUVER—It is clear that the environmental movement is against everything from cars to logging to the tar sands—but what is it in favour of?

Apart from industry-backed government reforms and massive “climate summits,” and despite considerable anxiety among affected populations about immediately combating climate change, little has been done to institute systemic, lasting change. The need to address the root causes of ecological crises is widely perceived, though. A November 2010 Environics poll showed that 85 per cent of Canadians “agree the root cause of climate change is too much focus on economic growth and consumerism” and want “an economy that is in harmony with nature, which recognizes and respects the planet.”

Faced with the ongoing failure of world powers and business leaders to take meaningful action, ordinary people have taken matters into their own hands. In April 2010, over 30,000 people met in Cochabamba, Bolivia, for the first World Peoples Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth (PWCCC).

The World Peoples Conference, along with other grassroots efforts like the World Social Forum, represent a tangible rejection of representational politics and, crucially, a powerful belief in the right of people to have a direct say in matters that deeply concern them. Compelled to revolutionary action in part by the same desire to allow people to decide their own fate, the Zapatista Army of National Liberation (EZLN) announced themselves to Mexico and the world alike over 16 years ago. Deeply rooted in Indigenous struggles, this autonomous movement provides a resounding example for resistance everywhere.

In EZLN spokesperson Subcommandate Marcos’s own words, “We do not want others...to decide for us. We want to participate directly in the decisions which concern us, to control those who govern us, without regard to their political affiliation, and oblige them to ‘rule by obeying.’”

Here in British Columbia, where almost all lands are unceded Indigenous territories, the ever-expanding drive to profit from private control over resources has continued unabated since the first waves of colonization and settlement. Backed by police and security forces, and often in contempt of the will and sovereignty of affected communities, every level of government has done its best to auction off the ecologically diverse lands and resources between the coast and the Rockies to the highest corporate bidder.

Case in point is the vast array of energy and mining projects awaiting near-certain approval in the environmental assessment process, described by the government as a potential $52 billion investment in BC. The proposed Mount Milligan copper and gold mine in Nak’azdli and Treaty 8 territory north of Prince George was green-lighted in the fall of 2010. If it goes ahead, Mount Milligan will be the second-most expensive construction project in the province, coming in just after the $966 million RCMP station being built in Surrey.

Resistance to these and other projects is ongoing. In late 2010, Enbridge’s proposed Northern Gateway oil pipeline, planned to “link the tar sands to Asia through [First Nations] territories and the [Fraser] headwaters,” was loudly opposed by dozens of Indigenous nations. Asserting their own sovereign and collective vision for their lands and communities in the Save the Fraser Declaration, the signing nations stated: “This project...and the federal process to approve it, violates our laws, traditions, values and our inherent rights as Indigenous peoples under international law. We are united to exercise our inherent title, rights and responsibility to ourselves, our ancestors, our descendants and to the people of the world, to defend these lands and waters. Our laws require that we do this.”

In Cochabamba, PWCCC participants identified key features of the capitalist economy, including “free” markets and private control of the means of life for profit, as bearing the brunt of responsibility for the climate crisis.

Together with the market economy, which fails to account for so-called “externalities” (such as pollution) come the private property rights that underpin the entire economic system. These rights allow control over a productive resource which may not directly be used or occupied by its “owner,” like a factory in China owned by American investors, or an apartment where people pay rent to an absentee landlord.

By excluding others from access, private property empowers owners to compel others to labour on their property for a minimal wage, effectively enabling proprietors to live comfortably off the sweat of others. Crucially, as the Cochabamba Peoples Agreement observes, this vast system also transforms “everything into commodities: water, earth, the human genome, ancestral cultures, biodiversity, justice, ethics, the rights of peoples, and life itself.”

Demanding nothing less than an “absolute rejection of the privatization, monetization and mercantilization of nature,” the PWCCC called for forging “a new system that restores harmony with nature and among human beings,” drawing from anti-oppression principles and based upon “complementarity, solidarity and equality [and] collective well-being.”

Imagining this new system and working to build it together with people in East Vancouver, across unceded British Columbia, and with people in struggle around the world, is the urgent task that we today have at hand.

Visit vancouver.mediacoop.ca regularly for the latest in local, grassroots news and reporting from the Vancouver Media Co-op.

Green Socialism’s Road to Nowhere


VANCOUVER—It’s been four months since I attended the protests against the 16th UN Conference of Parties (COP-16), where world leaders met to come to a consensus on the crisis of climate change. It was already known ahead of time that no significant agreement to determine the future of the planet was going to be reached. But I didn’t go there to report on the closed-door meetings of the elites. I went with the hope of finding a more radical analysis of what activists need to do to save life on the planet. What I found instead was a divided movement where egos, dead political ideologies and media stunts ruled the scene.

The majority of activists who traveled to the Yucatan peninsula stayed in one of two camps, either at Via Campesina or Espacio Mexicano. Infighting between these two groups split the already small crowd.

I stayed at Via Campesina, where the Anti-C@P anarchists, an autonomous group not affiliated with the camp, were organizing and hosting events. The moment I entered the camp, I was greeted with the smiling faces of Fidel Castro, Hugo Chavez and Evo Morales printed on giant posters. No workshops or discussions were planned. In true socialist fashion, the conversation flowed in one direction: from the top down.

The day of the “big march,” where the protestors were supposed to declare their demands, saw only two tiny marches that didn’t converge. The Via Campesina demo was to walk towards Cancunmesse, where world leaders were deciding how to cash in on the crisis. My mood brightened at the festive vibe in the streets and the diversity of groups from all over the world. Most people I spoke with agreed that capitalism has to be stopped in order to stop the destruction of nature. Many did not agree with the discourse being doled out from the stage at the Via camp, seeing the platform as a socialist version of “greenwashing.” Hearing all this gave me hope.

Then the march stopped. A truck was blocking the highway, inexplicably put there by people from Via Campesina, still several kilometers from Cancunmesse. Protesters were warned about going past the truck. Then the speechifying that dominated the re-education camp resumed along this road to nowhere. While many people lay on the tarmac and went to sleep, I crossed the “line” only to find that someone had spray-painted the truck: “We will not be stopped.”

Out of the corner of my eye, I saw a giant silver hammer moving towards the security fence. The 50-foot inflatable mallet was being carried by members of Anti-C@P, who slammed it against the wall creating a giant “KABOOM!” This symbolic act broke the spell conjured by the security apparatus and movement managers, and sent the strongest, clearest message of the entire convergence: in order to save the earth, capitalism must not just be stopped, but smashed.

Franklin Lopez is a Vancouver-based filmmaker, activist and editor member of the Vancouver Media Co-op. He is currently touring North America with his film END:CIV.

These stories were published in A People's Forecast: The Climate Justice Issue, our 2011 special issue. To read more articles as they are published, click here.

Own your media. Support the Dominion. Join the Media Co-op today.



Wow, you people are severely unhinged. The problems of the World are other people's fault and you have an answer. I hope you self aware enough to recognize what drivel this is.

Archived Site

This is a site that stopped updating in 2016. It's here for archival purposes.

The Dominion is a monthly paper published by an incipient network of independent journalists in Canada. It aims to provide accurate, critical coverage that is accountable to its readers and the subjects it tackles. Taking its name from Canada's official status as both a colony and a colonial force, the Dominion examines politics, culture and daily life with a view to understanding the exercise of power.

»Where to buy the Dominion